Cultural Anthropology: Providing a deeper understanding of culture for global safe technologies and trust and safety

www.trustandsafety.xyz

Download a PDF version of the article here

In the ever-evolving landscape of technology, Trust & Safety (T&S) teams are tasked with a complex mission: ensuring that digital platforms remain safe, inclusive for all, and respectful of all. While technical solutions and policy frameworks are essential, cultural anthropology is a less obvious but equally crucial tool in the T&S arsenal.

What is cultural anthropology, and why does it matter?

Cultural anthropology is a field of study within anthropology that focuses on understanding the diverse ways in which humans live and create meaning in their lives. It examines the cultural variations among different societies and how these cultures shape people's beliefs, practices, and social interactions.

Technology and material culture

Anything from basic hand tools and work clothing to high-tech machinery, electronics/gadgets, or infrastructure.

Creation and Use: How artifacts are made, altered, and used in a particular culture. It is also a description of the skills and knowledge, as well as social practices, associated with production and use.

Meaning and Symbolism: Symbolism—physical items that metonymize emotions and values. They signify social class, statements of selfhood, or belief in the religious and personal belief systems.

Impact on Society: The adoption of new technologies or changes in material culture can influence social organization, economic systems, and even political structures.

Adaptation and Change: How societies change their material culture in response to changes like those of the environment, cultural contact, or technological innovation

Social Organization

Behavioral affiliation: the common patterns of ways in which individuals and groups relate to each other; associations as well as organizations and structures that govern human interactions within a society.

Kinship: a complex system of family and ancestral relationships that includes marriage rules, inheritance practices, and obligations between relatives.

Social Groups: After family, a society divides itself into multiple groups depending on interests, identity, or aspirations. These may be by age, gender (or an intersection of both), based on occupation, faith group, and a myriad of others.

Society, Status, and Roles: Societies create systems of responsibility, roles, and hierarchy; they have been around for thousands of years. They lead to maintaining the status of each person (leader, elder, warrior) and all roles that come with them.

Social Institutions: formalized structures that maintain and enforce social norms, including education systems, legal systems, religious institutions, and economic systems.

Power and Authority: System of distributing power in a society, style on how to resolve conflicts. It includes social relationships, such as in the family and community, or institutions that are governed by informal rules.

Economies

The economics goes far beyond the traditional markets and financial systems emphasis. It examines how societies develop, produce, distribute, and consume goods and services in ways that are deeply connected with cultural meanings and values.

Production: What are societies' inputs and outputs in terms of resources that become the goods and services available to members? This included hunting, agriculture, manufacturing,, or services. Industries study the production techniques, including those methods of making tools and technology employed by people (as practitioners call them) or their style of organization.

Distribution and Exchange: How do goods and services circulate or are passed in society? Reciprocity (gift-giving, barter), redistribution (by central authorities), and market exchange using currency.

Consumption: In what way do people use services and consume resources? The study of consumption patterns, the symbolism of material objects, and the cultural meaning assigned to food, clothing, and other things.

Values and meanings: the cultural values and beliefs related to economic activities. These might include, for example, sharing and reciprocity in some societies or the accumulation of wealth by an individual at any cost. Income Equality and how cultural backgrounds influence economic behavior.

Economic Systems and Means of Livelihood: What are the different economic systems present, in various cultures? Their examples include hunter-gatherer and pastoralist societies as well as agricultural (and some industrial) economies. Through their different livelihoods, anthropologists study these social structures and cultural practices.

Political and legal systems

Political and legal systems are a study of how societies are organized in terms of power, authority, and social control. This spans looking at different government structures, law, and order, on one hand, to dispute resolution on the other, and decision-making processes.

Power and Authority: How is power distributed and exercised within a society. Key Personnel and How They Are Selected or Designated by What Authority (Tradition, Charism, Legal Mandate?)

Government Structures: How are governments formed (monarchies, democracies, and theocracies)? How do these systems work and what are the duties of various institutions (councils, courts, and legislatures)?

Law and Social Control: What is the system of written and unwritten laws in society? How are rules made, implemented, and monitored? How do members of a society resolve disputes and maintain social order?

Conflict and Conflict Resolution: How are conflicts in societies resolved? How are disputes typically resolved based on background customs (e.g., mediation, negotiation, adjudication)? What is the impact of conflict on social relationships and power?

Decision-Making Processes: How do different societies make decisions? Is decision-making hierarchical, group-oriented, or based on consensus? What influence do cultural values and beliefs have over them when making decisions?

Language/Linguistics

Linguistics is not just watching what people are saying; it is also studying the language itself. It goes into how language influences culture, identity, and social relationships, as well as how power works! It studies how humans use speech to communicate, articulate their thoughts, and gain an understanding of the world.

Linguistic Relativity (Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis): The structure of a language affects how its speakers can conceptualize their world. Simply put, the language you speak shapes how you think.

Socio-Linguistics: This field investigates variations in language concerning social groups and situations. It essentially analyzes how language use and meaning are affected by age, gender, social class, ethnicity, and common geographical convergence.

Discourse Analysis: An approach to understanding how language in everyday talk and text is used to make meaning, produce social identities, and exercise power.

Ethnography of Communication: This includes the process of observing and documenting how language is used within a community or culture, which helps in determining these specific groups' norms and values through communication practices.

Ideologies and religions

The study of ideologies and religions delves into the systems of beliefs, values, and practices that shape how individuals and societies perceive and interact with the world. These systems encompass not only organized religions but also secular belief systems, political ideologies, and cultural worldviews.

Belief Systems: These are the fundamental ideas and tenets that people hold about the nature of reality, morality, and the purpose of life. They can include religious doctrines, philosophical principles, or secular ideologies.

Values: These are the principles and standards that guide behavior and decision-making. They are often derived from belief systems and can vary significantly across cultures.

Rituals and Practices: These are the symbolic actions and ceremonies that express and reinforce beliefs and values. They can include religious worship, social customs, and rites of passage.

Social Functions: Ideologies and religions serve various social functions, such as providing meaning and purpose, promoting social cohesion, reinforcing social norms, and legitimizing power structures.

Symbolism: Ideologies and religions are often expressed through symbols, stories, myths, and rituals that convey deeper meanings and connect individuals to their cultural heritage.

Health and Illness

It is important because understanding health and illness cannot only be done through the biomedical model — distribution of power, social variation, and cultural construction. Rather, it looks at how various cultures view, live with, and react to health and illness, acknowledging the heavy sway of social-cultural-environmental influences.

Cultural Conceptions of Health: The definition and interpretation of health may differ based on your cultural background. Physical strength and health; mental steadiness, straight thinking, or emotional balance—all are desirable traits that appeal to different people in light of their worldview.

Cultural Explanations of Illness: cultural concepts promoting specific beliefs and practices common to a culture that influence how people understand the causes of illness. Such explanations may involve supernatural forces, imbalances in the body, or social transgressions.

Cultural Explanations of Illness: Cultures practice a variety of healing techniques, from traditional medicinal or ritual cures, to medical approaches. Such practices are often linked to cultural ideals and assumptions about the body, well-being, and mental health.

Social Determinants of Health: Socioeconomic status, gender, and ethnicity are just a few examples, otherwise known as the determinants of health, that influence outcomes. Health disparities within and across societies generate micro-needs for examination by cultural anthropologists to understand how these social determinants together shape patterns. SetKeyName

Medical pluralism: people combine traditional and modern medicine in many societies. This indicates that his utilization of health-seeking behavior is a complex interaction between cultural beliefs and practical necessity.

Social Change

Societal transformation and culture change are social changes happening over time.

Social structures: altered family roles, sex-role definitions, class structure, and community organization.

Cultural Values and Norms: Changes in a society's beliefs, attitudes, and norms.

Economic Systems: This is also seen in economic system transformation (from, for example, agriculture to industrialization).

Political Systems: Changes related to governance, power, and laws.

Technological Advancements: How new technologies can put us all under the microscope with unique implications for our social lives and everyday cultures.

By understanding these diverse aspects of human culture, T&S professionals can gain invaluable insights into the nuanced ways that people from different backgrounds interact with technology.

Cultural Anthropology in Action: T&S Applications

AI and algorithms

The problem is that machine learning models are based on data, and the data inherently has biases and assumptions. Cultural understanding makes the identification of these biases necessary to reduce them in AI systems.

Policy Development

Policies should be sensitive to the culture. What is socially acceptable for one culture may not be so in others. Anthropological understanding will provide context in shaping user-specific policies that recognize the different backgrounds of global users.

Safety by Design

To design platforms that are safer by design for disparate user groups, it is essential to be cognizant of the fact that privacy, acceptance, freedom of expression, and safe connections as cultural norms stand true universally as behaviors around online use and interaction.

Moderation Teams

The most obvious front line of T&S is the moderators. Arming them with cultural savviness enables a heightened ability to discern the meanings of materials and user behavior, especially in multicultural scenarios.

Moderator Wellbeing

Moderators are exposed to harmful content daily. Understanding the psychological and cultural impact of this exposure can lead to better support systems for their mental health.

The direct learnings from cultural anthropology that can be interwoven with trust and safety work

Understanding technology and material culture

Cultural context: Understanding what it means to use technology for people that come from different backgrounds is critical to informing culturally sensitive policies and moderation practices.

How Technologies Change Behavior (Use of Case): It exemplifies how specific platforms reshape the way users behave and place them, which can be used to reveal risks and design safety policies.

Technological Impact: It helps in predicting the social and cultural effects of new technologies as they empower societies.

Recommended by LinkedIn

Saving the world by talking to people

Social Organization

Understanding Community Dynamics: Similar to individual identity, social organization influences how people connect and form online communities in socio-semantic clouds. If teams such as T&S are aware of these dynamics, they would be able to understand how unsafe content or behaviors might propagate in a particular (large) subset.

Addressing Power Imbalances: Addressing the Kinds of Social Hierarchies that Are Root Causes for Online Harassment, Discrimination, and Exploitation. These power imbalances need to be accounted for in T&S policies, which must insulate the most vulnerable.

Interpreting Cultural Symbols: One way to indicate belonging, identity, or otherness is via symbolism. T&S professionals must understand the meanings of symbols, and artifacts to evaluate content by intent.

Moderation in Cultural Context: Understanding the Core Principles of Various Social Norms Something licit in one culture may be insulting to the other. Moderators have to be capable of making educated decisions and understanding the implications of the outcome.

Designing Culturally Relevant Safety Features: The layering in the development part should take into account that social organization and material culture are varied among different user groups. Community-based as well as individualistic reporting mechanisms should be efficient.

Anticipating Social Change: A social system and material culture constantly change. To this end, T&S teams should continuously monitor cultural changes and adjust their approach to target imminent risks. Social organization is a huge part of trust and safety in the long term because it helps specialized teams like this anticipate how different communities might respond to online content or policies. For example, a policy that looks like it may not result in harm to others might do so if implemented on a collectivist societal scale. Acknowledging these cultural differences allows T&S professionals to make online spaces safer and more welcoming.

Economies

Understanding User Motivations: By understanding how different cultures value and exchange goods, services, and information, T&S teams can better anticipate user behavior on platforms. This includes recognizing the motivations behind creation, sharing, and engagement, which can be crucial in identifying potential risks and vulnerabilities.

Addressing Economic Exploitation: Cultural knowledge helps T&S professionals identify and address economic exploitation on platforms, such as scams, fraud, and unfair practices. Recognizing cultural norms around financial transactions and relationships is key to developing effective policies and interventions.

Mitigating Economic Disparities: Economic disparities can lead to social unrest and conflict, both online and offline. Understanding the economic contexts of different communities can help T&S teams design policies that promote fairness, reducing the risk of grievances and harmful behavior.

Protecting Vulnerable Groups: Certain economic systems may marginalize specific groups, making them more vulnerable to online harms like exploitation, abuse, or discrimination. Cultural awareness enables T&S teams to tailor protections for these groups and ensure their voices are heard.

Building Trust Through Fair Practices: Platforms that demonstrate a commitment to fair economic practices, such as transparent pricing, equitable compensation for content creators, and responsible advertising, are more likely to earn the trust of users. This trust, in turn, contributes to a safer and more positive online environment.

Navigating Cross-Cultural Transactions: In the global digital landscape, transactions, and interactions often occur across cultural boundaries. Understanding the different economic norms and expectations of diverse user groups is essential for building trust and preventing misunderstandings that could lead to conflict or harm.

Designing Culturally Relevant Safety Measures: Economic factors play a role in how people perceive and respond to online risks. By understanding the economic contexts of different user groups, T&S teams can design safety measures that are culturally relevant and effective in protecting users from harm.

Political and Legal Systems

Content moderation (political speech vs. online activism) varies from culture to culture. T&S teams must appreciate the political environments of different localities for proper decisions on content moderation, ensuring they do not curtail legitimate political speech but also manage harmful forms of expression.

Regulatory Compliance: This means that platforms operate in different legal jurisdictions, where regulations on speech are also very varied. Having T&S teams with political and legal knowledge allows them to maneuver these difficult legal landscapes and be compliant with local law.

Governance of platforms: Online platforms are, at times, quasi-political entities with their own rules and governance systems. A better understanding of how different cultures approach governance can help in designing rules for platforms that are legitimate and effective across borders.

When Political Atmospheres Turn Hostile: In conflict areas or when political tensions rise in a region, online platforms carry misinformation and hate speech just as much, if not more, than any kind of violence. Therefore, they require a nuanced cultural lens to appreciate and counter risk on these platforms in the interest of keeping users safe.

Cross-Cultural Collaboration: T&S professionals need to work with colleagues and stakeholders from different cultural contexts. Effective collaboration arises when parties comprehend different political and legal perspectives.

Language/Linguistics

Content Moderation: Language accuracy is a critical factor for content moderation. Moderators should have linguistic knowledge to interpret nuances, slang, and context-specific meanings that can get lost in translation. This is important for platforms operating in multilingual and multicultural settings on the web.

Fighting Hate Speech and Harassment: Hate speech and harassment often rely on subtle linguistic cues and coded language. Cultural understanding enables T&S teams to identify and address harmful content that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Constructing Inclusive Communities: Acknowledging linguistic diversity and using inclusive language is critical for a community member when creating an online space where anyone can feel welcomed or respected. This makes us think twice about the repercussions of words for marginalized groups.

Cross-Cultural Communication: In the global networked world, it is vital to communicate effectively across different cultural environments. Cultural awareness prevents misunderstandings and builds trust and engagement for better T&S interactions.

User Feedback Analysis: User feedback can tell a lot about their experience on the platform, so this is an obvious choice. Cultural knowledge helps T&S teams interpret feedback correctly, considering the cultural environment in which the response was provided.

Creating Culturally Appropriate Policies: T&S policies need to take linguistic diversity and cultural norms into account. This entails refraining from using language that could be offensive, or exclusionary to specific groups and making certain these policies are accessible in many different languages.

Teaching AI Models: Content moderation uses language models, unfortunately, they must be taught on lots of real-world data that matches the linguistics and cultural diversity of the end-users. Cultural competence can also help protect against bias in these models and improve their prediction accuracy.

Ideologies and religions

Content Moderation: Religious and ideologically motivated content can be difficult to understand or offensive. T&S teams must understand the culture to decide what content is detrimental or inappropriate. This means knowing the ins and outs of religious texts, images, and practices while also identifying how extremist ideology can proliferate online.

User Behavior: Ideologies and religions shape how people interact online. Understanding these influences helps T&S professionals anticipate potential conflicts, identify harmful behavior, and tailor interventions accordingly. For example, certain religious groups may have specific online communication norms that need to be respected.

Community Guidelines: They should be rooted in broad fact. Community guidelines should accommodate diverse beliefs. The insights from cultural anthropology are essential in shaping regulations to preserve the space for freedom of expression online and everything else that comes with it without having hate speech being passed on legally or ideational harm based on differences like religious beliefs, etc.

Preventing Bias: Algorithms and decision-making processes by T&S can be influenced by the unconscious bias of religion, and beliefs. If we are to be in a course of fairness and ethically treat all users, then these biases need to have more light cast on them.

Resolution of Conflicts: Internet conflicts sometimes result from ideological or religious differences. This cultural insight allows T&S teams to intervene in these conflicts, facilitating dialogue and understanding instead of turning them into confrontations.

Safeguarding the vulnerable: Several religious and ideological groups can be susceptible to online harassment, discrimination,, or targeted attacks. The T&S teams have to identify these weak points and come up with tactics for protecting them.

Health and illness

Destigmatization and sensitivity: It is important to consider cultural perceptions of health and sickness as part of moderating content. Recently, we have seen a rise in stakes around what could be perceived as misleading health information that would in certain cultures be deemed dangerous or reckless but equally considered by others to simply be an expression of faith.

Cultural awareness: This skill is necessary for T&S teams to have more clarity in selecting content, which can avoid inadvertent stereotyping and discrimination against different communities.

Health Misinformation: Health misinformation can be dangerous. Cultural facts inform us of the misinformation that specifically targets these cultural groups or manipulates their customs and weaknesses. Local T&S teams can then create context-specific strategies to combat misinformation and disseminate facts about healthcare being implemented in their regions.

Supporting Vulnerable Communities: Some specific cultural populations may be at higher risk due to the encumbrance of health risks due to social determinants such as poverty, discrimination, or lack of access to healthcare. Community leaders and frontline health workers can work with T&S teams to tackle these inequalities that endanger vulnerable populations online.

Promoting Mental Health: In many cultures, mental health is a sensitive topic to talk about. Understanding those norms is essential for T&S teams to identify both community members and themselves.

Social change

Adapting to Evolving Risks: With a changing demographic, society is topped with new forms of threats and risks. For example, the advent of social media has spawned new avenues for cyberbullying, hate speech, and the propagation of fake news. To address these changing risks, T&S teams must proactively factor in this evolving scenario while designing strategies.

Recognizing Shifts in User Behavior: As society changes, so do the ways people behave on online networks. Just as cultural values and norms develop, their communication forms of expression are also becoming more complex. These changes underscore the importance of T&S. professionals to keep pace with these shifts and for policies and moderation practices to stay current and appropriate.

Identifying Emerging Vulnerabilities: At times, social change can be a cause and result in the production of a new vulnerability group. So, for example, is one of rapid technological change that tends to impact older populations less familiar with good online safety practices. With this intricate aspect of social change, T&S teams can use their knowledge to recognize and shield at-risk populations.

Developing Relevant Solutions: In a rapidly changing world, there is no single culture in which online platforms operate. T&S strategies should be attuned and responsive to the particular needs, opportunities, and challenges different communities encounter. These can include delivering safety measures, educational resources,, or support services that are customized to different cultural contexts.

Fostering Trust in Times of Change: Online platforms are hard-won, and trust might be quickly lost during times of social tumult or rapid change. The trust and safety teams build by doing so demonstrate an understanding of the social and cultural dynamics at play, as well as a commitment to users' protection.

The Future of T&S: Culturally Informed Safety

Given how technology is evolving to shape our world, culturally intelligent T&S practices are only going to become more urgent; the growth potential for this industry has no ceiling. If we adopt this model, which celebrates the complexity of human culture, then the whole internet can be welcoming to everyone.

But cultural anthropology is not an academic exercise; it has been used as a practice tool that can redefine the way we execute trust and safety. The only way that we can create safer, more fair, and more just online spaces is to understand the cultural contexts in which people use technology.